Thursday, 26 August 2021

Concerns of anti-democracy raised during debate

 At a special meeting of the Comhairle on Wednesday, 25th August, a majority of councillors voted to consult on a corporate strategy 2022-27 with a view to implementation before a new council is elected.

Concerns were raised by SNP Group leader, Cllr Gordon Murray that there was no mandate to do this.

Cllr Murray stated in the debate:

"The corporate strategy or manifesto is hugely important and gives political direction for the next five years 2022-27."

"What we have here today is not democracy. From what I understand, no elected member has had a direct input into this manifesto."

"If passed today, the process of implementation will continue and the newly elected councillors will be bound to a manifesto that they did not agree to and that the people did not vote on and which has been put together on bureaucratic principles and not democratic principles."

"Lets treat our electorate with respect and not contempt and allow the new council, whoever they may be to chart the political direction for this local authority."

Amendment put forward by Cllr Murray and seconded by Cllr John Mitchell was as follows:

The council, wishing to ensure that the democratic process is fully respected, agrees to defer final consideration of the corporate strategy 2022-27 until June 2022 so as to allow for a full consultation with all affected stakeholders and communities across the Western Isles in order to allow the newly elected members to consider the Corporate Strategy particularly in the areas of renewable energy"

Councillors who voted against amendment:

Cllr Norman Macdonald - convenor

Cllr Roddie Mackay - leader

Cllr Paul Steele

Cllr Roddy Mackay

Cllr Iain Macleod

Cllr Paul Finnegan

Cllr Finlay Stewart

Cllr Keith Dodson

Cllr Rae Mackenzie

Cllr Angus McCormack

Cllr Charlie Nicoolson

Cllr Neil Mackay

Cllr Donald Crichton

Cllr John Mackay

Cllr Kenny John Macleod

Councillors who voted for amendment:

Cllr Calum Macmillan

Cllr Iain Archie Macneil

Cllr John Mitchell

Cllr Gordon Murray

Cllr John A Maciver